Federal judge to hear arguments on Hawaii's lawsuit against revised travel ban

Miranda GreerMar 17, 2017

In his decision granting the temporary restraining order, Federal District Judge Derrick Watson rejected the government's argument that the travel restrictions do not amount to a Muslim ban, and only probing Trump's "veiled psyche" and "secret motives" would turn up evidence of religious discrimination.

Watson wrote that the plaintiffs had a "strong likelihood of success on the merits" in their attempt to overturn the order. Today's decision is a victory for the rule of law and reminder that no one - not even the president - is above the Constitution.

Shortly after Watson's decision came down, Chuang similarly ruled that the likely goal of the order was "the effectuation of the proposed Muslim ban" that Trump had called for during the 2016 campaign. "If this is implemented, it will have devastating consequences for our communities". Taking certain language out of the executive order does not mean that the administration's intent can no longer be considered by a court.

Like the Hawaii judge, Chuang cited Trump's negative statements about Muslim immigrants during the campaign.

Describing it as a "highly unique case", Chuang wrote: "The record provides strong indications that the national security goal is not the primary objective for the travel ban". "But it's countries that have tremendous terror... countries that people are going to come in and cause us tremendous problems".

During a rally on Wednesday night, Trump decried the ruling and defended a previous version of the executive order that was also stalled by the courts.

Trump policy adviser Stephen Miller has said the revised order was created to have "the same basic policy outcome" as the first. "We're going to fight this awful ruling".

Two more judges, one in Maryland and another in Washington, heard arguments Wednesday on whether to freeze the order. It spurred protests around the country and was blocked by a federal judge in Seattle and then an appeals court. We're going to take this as far as we need to, right up to the Supreme Court.

"A review of the historical background here makes plain why the Government wishes to focus on the Executive Order's text, rather than its context".

"You don't think that this was done by a judge for political reasons, do you", Trump asked, before drawing out a dramatic and sarcastic, "Noooo".

Trump's discriminatory Muslim and refugee ban, in any iteration, is a clear example of how this administration uses the politics of fear and hate to enact its xenophobic agenda.

Related Articles:



« Previous article


Popular Pages

Laid-off workers a priority as China cuts overcapacity, Premier says
In his press conference after the parliament meeting, Li said that a "substantive progress" is now made for the code's draft.

Malaysia got DNA from Kim's son overseas: deputy PM
Zahid yesterday said Jong-nam's identity was confirmed based on DNA sample comparisons with one of the deceased's children. Rising tensions between the two nations have seen both banning the other's citizens from leaving their country.

Federal judge not ready to rule on blocking new travel ban
But Robart was unwilling to extend his initial ruling to over the second order, saying that a new motion would have to be filed. New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman in a statement called the executive order "a Muslim ban by another name".

Starbucks gets artsy with spring bevy cups
Starting on March 16, coffee lovers will be be able to sip on their lattes that are served in the new spring cups. The cups will be available beginning March 16 at Starbucks stores in the U.S. and Canada for a limited time.

Team Israel suffers first loss in World Baseball Classic
Israel's national team suffered its first setback at the World Baseball Classic on Monday, losing to the Netherlands in Tokyo. Israel has one game remaining in the round, with a Wednesday morning matchup against host Japan still on the docket.

Tesla pledges to fix Australian state's power woes
South Australia's population of 1.7 million people suffer regular power cuts and energy shortages. He plans to do the same by building a massive 100 MW battery storage farm in the said time frame.

Joe Biden Is Back and Ready to Take Down Cancer
Biden did, however, note that the current administration's failure to embrace the concept of global warming "frustrates" him. Obama then handed Biden the reins to lead the program meant to accelerate cancer research in America.

Karan Avtar Singh appointed new Chief Secretary of Punjab
The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), which is in power in the National Capital Territory of Delhi, was a distant second with 20 seats. On 11 March, Congress had a landslide victory in the Punjab polls as it won 77 seats in the 117-seat Assembly.

Malcolm Butler Set to Visit With New Orleans Saints
The Patriots don't have a first, or second-round pick, so keep that in mind as the Patriots look to potentially trade Butler. The Saints and Patriots have a history of making trades with each other, with the Cooks deal as the latest example.

Anbang denies investment in Trump son-in-law's flagship NY office block
A White House spokesman told Bloomberg that Kushner will recuse himself from subjects such as the EB-5 visa program. The negotiations may lead to a federal review like it did when Anbang was looking to purchase the Waldorf Astoria.