Despite gains, LGBT protections remain a patchwork in US

Darin HammondApr 06, 2017

A dissenting opinion criticizes the majority on a Chicago federal appeals court for becoming the first to rule that the 1964 Civil Rights Act protects LGBT employees from workplace discrimination.

CHICAGO (AP) — A ruling by a US appeals court in Chicago could reopen the question of whether the 1964 Civil Rights Act's protections apply to LGBT workers in the same way they bar discrimination based on someone's race, religion or national origin.

Existing federal law specifically cites race, color, religion, sex, and national origin as protected groups in the workplace, but is mum about whether that also covers sexual orientation.

The Supreme Court typically agrees to take up an issue when it sees judicial discord between nation's 13 USA circuit courts.

The 7th Circuit only has jurisdiction over Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin, which means the ruling will not apply nationally.

"This decision is game changer for lesbian and gay employees facing discrimination in the workplace and sends a clear message to employers: it is against the law to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation", said Greg Nevins, a Lambda Legal strategist.

In her lawsuit, Hively said that Ivy Tech Community College in South Bend passed her over for a permanent position and refused to renew her contract as an adjunct professor after school administrators learned she is a lesbian.

Writing for the majority, the Seventh Circuit's Chief Judge Diane Wood (a Clinton appointee) acknowledged that the decision in Hively v. Ivy Tech required taking a "fresh look" at previous rulings by federal appeals courts "in light of developments at the Supreme Court extending over two decades".

Hively said after Tuesday's ruling that she agreed to bring the case because she felt she was being "bullied".

But several of those judges came down on the side of LGBTQ protection, including Judge Richard Posner, who was appointed by Ronald Reagan.

Ivy Tech said on Tuesday night that it does not intend to appeal the case to the Supreme Court.

The decision comes as President Donald Trump's administration has begun setting its own policies on LGBT rights. "We congratulate plaintiff Kimberly Hively, Lambda Legal and all the attorneys who helped achieve this victory". In January President Trump promised not to revoke President Obama's executive order banning federal contractors from discriminating against workers due to their sexual orientation or identity, but last week Trump quietly rolled back some of those protections.

The dissent was written by Judge Diane Sykes, who though conceding that Hively "was treated unjustly" if she had been fired due to being a lesbian, argued that "Title VII does not provide a remedy for this kind of discrimination". He said the Seventh Circuit's approach to the Civil Rights Act was a momentous shift from past cases. "That means that it falls within Title VII's prohibition against sex discrimination".

Related Articles:

« Previous article

Popular Pages

US Congress rolls back family planning funding protections
The Title X grant of the Public Health Service Act is the only federal program focused exclusively on providing family planning. Every single Democrat voted against the bill, and every Republican, with the exception of two women , voted for it.

AP findings on Trump associate's work for Russian oligarch
Now, as the focus on Manafort's ties to Russian Federation increases, descriptions of his place in the campaign have shrunk. Mr Manafort confirmed that he worked for Mr Deripaska but said the work was being unfairly cast as inappropriate.

Epps sorry for dancing with kangaroo on stage
According to Epps, the original plan was to have the kangaroo run across the stage as a joke, but that's not how it played out. He later posted an apology note to his social media account, and said he would be donating to a kangaroo conservation charity.

Dolphins' offseason workouts begin April 17; mandatory minicamp set for June
Voluntary offseason workout programs are meant to provide training, teaching and physical conditioning for players. Phase two: The following three weeks may include on-field workouts, individual player instruction and drills.

EC issuing political statement on EVM tampering: AAP
He also reiterated the demand for use of traditional method of ballot papers in all future elections till the time the doubts about EVMs are not cleared.

'Game Of Thrones' Season 7 Promo "Long Walk"
In the North, Jon Snow ( Kit Harington ) reluctantly takes his place at the Great Hall of Winterfell as the new Lord of the North. This seems probable since Daenerys made an alliance with the Greyjoy children in season 6 of " Game of Thrones ".

Prosecutors: Facebook assault victim was threatened with dog
Gardner said that both boys, identified from stills of the video, admitted to others that they had sexually assaulted the girl. Police continue to search for others involved in the attack, which took place in the Lawndale neighborhood.

Body-camera maker offers 1-year trial to police agencies
The company's official website is now "We're building a community, this is just the enabler", Smith said. More than 180,000 lives and countless dollars have been saved with Axon's network of devices, apps and people.

Trump to end support for UN Population Fund over abortions
Starting in 1979, China had a "one-child policy" enforced in many cases with state-mandated abortions. President Clinton restored the funding in 1993, before President George W.

Trump defends Fox News host O'Reilly as 'good person'
Ailes, who has denied all of the allegations against him, was forced to resign from Fox News just one week after that interview . Trump said that he didn't think O'Reilly should have settled with the women involved.