Experts Propose Changes To Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines

Judith QuinnApr 12, 2017

An independent US panel of experts has changed course on its recommendation against routine PSA screening of men for prostate cancer. The task force recommends that doctors have a conversation with their male patients who don't have signs or symptoms of the disease about the benefits and drawbacks of taking the prostate-specific antigen blood test.

So why the controversy? Because the test is imperfect, Brawley said, there are a number of missed cancers and false alarms.

The draft of the guidelines signals a major shift in prostate screening advice for men, which in 2012 discouraged testing for healthy men of any age. She is a chair in medicine and a professor of medicine, epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of California, San Francisco. "With active discussions between physicians and patients, individuals will be able to make the right decision for themselves". But first, they should have a talk with their doctor about the pros and the cons of the PSA test. When it appears in middle-aged men, it frequently develops so slowly that it's rarely the cause of death, so treating it with invasive and toxic therapies like surgery, chemotherapy and radiation often exposes men to more side effects and harms without protecting them from dying from that cancer.

In a grade D recommendation, the USPSTF continued to discourage PSA screening in men aged 70 and older.

"Given that most prostate cancers are slow growing, and given the risks of over-diagnosis and over-treatment, there is little evidence that men 70 and older benefit from PSA screening", said Dr. Quoc-Dien Trinh of the Brigham and Women's Hospital and Dana-Farber Cancer Institute Prostate Cancer Program in Boston. Other groups say start earlier, depending on family history of prostate cancer and other factors.

The revised draft recommendation is open to public comment before a final recommendation is issued. Men with prostate cancer may be candidates for surgery or radiation. The test comes with many potential problems but brings the benefit of ever so slightly reducing the chance of dying from the cancer.

Instead of treatment, many men with low-risk prostate cancer can opt for active surveillance, which may reduce the chance of overtreatment.

In the study, only about 1 percent of men died of prostate cancer over 10 years, with no significant differences between those who were treated and those who simply kept a watchful eye. "The right decision isn't screening all men, it's making all men aware of the benefits and harms, and then allowing each man to make the best decision for himself", Bibbins-Domingo explained. Patients should keep in mind that black men and those with a family history of prostate cancer are at greater risk, while also considering that PSA tests may lead to unnecessary procedures that have side effects like impotence and incontinence. The task force is charged with making "evidence-based" recommendations about clinical preventive services, including health screenings, counseling services and preventive medications. The potential harms of screening include frequent false-positive results, which can result in immediate, additional testing, and years of additional close monitoring with repeated blood tests and biopsies. It may also delay treatment and its complications, or avoid treatment completely, Bibbins-Domingo said.

Krist said the uncertainty at every step of the way in diagnosing and treating prostate cancer makes it crucial for men to discuss the options, and their concerns, with their doctors. However, Meigs said that he and other family doctors have come to depend on the task force's recommendations, which are known for sticking closely to the available evidence.

The fact that there are harms has been hard for many advocates of prostate cancer screening to accept.

Related Articles:

« Previous article
Next article »

Popular Pages

Derby hero Griezmann won't rule out Real Madrid move
Real Madrid were generally in control, however and looked happy to move the ball around as Atletico searched in vain for a chance. Atletico remain in third place after the draw, although just a point ahead of Sevilla in fourth, who beat Deportivo 4-2.

55 percent of Americans approve of Obamacare
I feel like we have the resources, the medical technology and everything in place to provide the health care to the people. Wow: Obamacare approval surges to 55% in favor, 41% against amid Republican repeal efforts, per new Gallup poll .

Full New York rail service expected, 4 days after derailment
And in the long term, NJ Transit should be more directly involved in the maintenance and operation of the terminal, Santoro said. New York City Transit honored LIRR tickets at Penn Station on the no 1, 2 and 3 lines and the A, C and E lines.

Feldman, Duvall spark Reds over Cardinals 8-0
Wacha, who had just 13 hits in 141 career at-bats (.092) entering the game, helped his own cause with an RBI single in the fourth. Louis has drawn in a game since May 22, 2011 and the most the Reds have allowed since a 16-inning game in 2009 in San Diego.

Bangladesh PM meets Indian opposition leader Sonia Gandhi
Banerjee's position is that the treaty would render north Bengal dry and affect farmers of her state. However, he said they are open to discussion on sharing the waters of joint rivers.

British lender Wonga warns customers of personal data hack
In a statement, the firm said: "We are working closely with authorities and we are in the process of informing affected customers. Be cautious of anyone who calls you and asks you to disclose any personal information regardless of where they say they are from.

S Korea Test Fires 800 Km-Range Missile
The European Union has expanded sanctions against North Korea over the country's nuclear tests and launches of ballistic missiles. North Korea fired a ballistic missile toward the Sea of Japan at 6:42 a.m. on Wednesday from the eastern coastal region of Sinpo.

Ford designs baby crib that mimics soothing auto ride
Parents can control all the effects of the Max Motor Dreams by using an app on their phone, from the comfort of their own bed. Ford says that it has no plans at the moment to produce and sell the crib, indicating that it's likely just a design concept.

Bookies slash odds on Arsenal ace Alexis Sanchez joining Tottenham to 3/1
However, the player reportedly wants to stay in England's capital and Ladbrokes have installed Spurs at odds of 3/1. Arsene Wenger has been left mystified by Arsenal fans' concerns over the future of Alexis Sanchez .

IS fighters in Mosul provoking coalition strikes on civilians
The CENTCOM commander went on to say that Islamic State (IS, former ISIS/ISIL) is most likely to have a hand in this tragedy. Just under 3,500 Iraqi troops were injured or killed during the three-month campaign to clear the eastern half, he said.